• By Liam Ridings
• In Blog
• Tags roofing materials

Cost Comparison of Different Roofing Materials: Metal, Shingles, & Tiles

Whether it’s for an industrial, commercial, or residential property, re-roofing any building is a major investment, and choosing the roofing materials for your property is a vital decision. By selecting suitable roofing materials for your property, you will significantly reduce long terms costs and save yourself potential headaches in the future.

With multiple roofing materials available in the market, it can be difficult to know where to start. While factors such as longevity, structure, and aesthetic of a roof are crucial, there is no denying the significant role that cost plays in the decision-making process. Therefore, educating yourself on the options available and the associated costs for each roofing option is essential.

This article will compare the costs of three popular roofing materials: metal, shingles, and tiles. By understanding the costs of these roofing materials, you will be primed with the information you need to choose the perfect option for your property.

1. Metal Roofing Cost in Australia

Metal roofing is very popular in Australia because of its durability, lower levels of roof maintenance, and resistance to diverse weather conditions. Metal roofs are sleek, simple to install, and made to withstand the harsh Australian sun.

Metal roofs are often made from various materials, including aluminium, copper, and steel. Each material has a unique set of benefits and its own set of costs. Therefore, the cost of metal roofing varies depending on the materials used and the complexity of the installation.

On average, metal roofing costs between $50-$180 per square metre for the materials and the installation combined. This vast variance in cost is a result of the different materials used. Generally, steel and aluminium are the most affordable materials, and copper is more expensive. Steel and aluminium will be on the lower end of this scale, at around $50-$100 per square metre, whereas copper can cost $180 per square metre, or sometimes as much as $400.

The cost is also affected by the roof profile, size, thickness, and finish. Understandably, detailed finishes and custom colours will add to the overall cost of the roof. Finally, it is crucial to always consider longevity and durability when choosing a roofing material. Metal roofs have a longer lifespan of up to 50 years, meaning you save money in the long run with lower maintenance and repair costs.

2. Shingle Roofing Cost in Australia

Shingle is a versatile option for property owners, with various colours and styles available. There are multiple shingle materials used for roofing in Australia, including wood, asphalt, and composite shingles.

Asphalt Shingles:

Asphalt shingles are the cheapest and most affordable option, generally costing between $35 and $80 per square metre for the materials and the installation. 

Wood Shingles:

Wood shingles offer a more natural and rustic aesthetic and are more expensive than asphalt. For the materials and installation, wood shingles cost between $80 and $160 per square metre.

Composite Shingles:

Composite shingles are made from recycled plastics and fibreglass and fall within a very similar price range as wood shingles (often between $70-140 per square metre).

The cost of shingle roofing depends on the type of shingle used, the quality of the materials, the complexity of the installation, and the local labour rates, so it can be challenging to estimate accurately. However, it is essential to consider the roofing material’s lifespan when deciding. While the cheaper upfront cost with shingle roofs is an appealing option for many, you need to account for future expenses that will come with more regular upkeep and maintenance.

3. Tile Roofing Cost in Australia

Tile roofing is another popular choice for property owners in Sydney, primarily due to the classic appearance, durability, and energy efficiency. The most common tiling materials used throughout Australia are concrete and terracotta. 

Concrete Tiles Vs Terracotta Tiles

Terracotta tiles are famous in Australia for their distinctive reddish-brown colour. Due to the durability and longer lifespan, they are more expensive than concrete tiles. Terracotta tiles will typically cost anywhere between $60 and $140 per square metre for the materials and installation. Concrete tiles are usually more affordable than terracotta tiles, ranging between $40 to $80 per square metre for materials and installation. 

Once again, it is important to factor in the requirement for ongoing maintenance. Over time, you will need to invest in your tile roof to ensure safety and security. For a lot of people, the ongoing work is worth the cost for the attractive aesthetic of the brick and the insulation it provides.

Comparing Roofing Material Costs: Metal, Shingles, & Tiles

Metal, shingle, and tile roofing materials have varying benefits, drawbacks, and costs. Choosing the right roof for your property depends on your preferences and priorities. Here is a simple guide to help determine which material is suitable for you.

When to Choose Metal Roofing:

Metal roofing is not the cheapest of the three options in terms of upfront costs, but you will get value for money in the long-run due to the longer lifespan, impressive durability, and low maintenance required. Moreover, it is possible to get affordable metal roofing in Sydney, and metal is great option for anyone living in New South Wales who is exposed to the harsh weather conditions and intense sunlight.

When to Choose Shingle Roofing:

If you are overly concerned about upfront costs, you’re looking to save some money, or just looking for a more short-term solution, shingle roofing is generally the most affordable option. Just be aware that shingle roofing will require more frequent maintenance and replacements, which can be costly in the future. Additionally, shingle roofs are not as durable as metal roofs and are not as resistant to the harsh Australian climate.

When to Choose Tile Roofing:

Tile roofing is a brilliant, middle-price option that combines durability and efficiency with aesthetics and visual appeal. Terracotta tiles provide the iconic reddish-brown look at a fair price, while concrete tiles provide a budget-friendly, durable material. Concrete tiles can withstand heavy rain, high winds, and harsh conditions. Tiled roofs will not require as much maintenance as shingle roofs but will still protect your home in various climates.

Conclusion

Choosing the most cost-effective roofing material will depend on your budget, how long you plan to stay in the property, the climate in your region, and your personal preferences. Metal, shingle, and tile roofing all provide unique benefits and drawbacks. By understanding these factors and the costs of each material, you can select the perfect roof to suit your budget and preferences, ensuring confidence in your roof for years to come.

At Vertec, we are the leading expert in roof installations, repairs, and maintenance. So, if you’re still unsure what the best roofing material for your property is, feel free to give us a call. Whether you have a roof that needs minor repairs or you’re looking to completely re-roof your property, we’ve got you covered.